top of page

Democracy Dies in Darkness-Or Does It?

Nov 11
4 min read

The Election is over.


The political ads have stopped (thank goodness), the votes have been counted, and we can all go back to watching commercials for things we don't need.  And not to make light of what just happened… many of us can breathe a sigh of relief that a majority of us agree on a shared vision for a world we want to see.


Last week though, I wrote about political campaigns as exercises in storytelling. The candidates, the characters, the conflicts, the carefully constructed narratives. My agenda here is not to write about politics, but politics, it seems, does have a great deal in common with the movies.


Now with the election is behind us, I've been thinking about storytelling from a slightly different perspective.


Is going to the movies is itself a form of civic participation?


Not in the traditional sense, of course. Nobody gets an "I Voted" sticker for buying a movie ticket. And I certainly wouldn't suggest that watching a film is a substitute for voting, volunteering, protesting, or otherwise getting involved.


But hear me out.


We live in a world in which we increasingly get to choose what we see, what we hear, and, perhaps most importantly, what we believe.


Our news feeds reflect our interests. Our streaming services recommend films based on what we've already watched. Our social media platforms serve up opinions that reinforce our own.

We can go through an entire day without encountering a single idea that seriously challenges the way we see the world.


And then we go to the movies.


For two hours, we enter someone else's life. Someone who may live in a country we've never visited, practice a religion we know little about, hold political beliefs we don't share, or face circumstances we can't begin to imagine.


We don't have to agree with them.


We don't even have to like them.


But for a little while, we're asked to understand them.


And isn't that, at least in part, what participating in a democracy requires?


The ability to recognize that other people have experiences, fears, hopes, and convictions that are every bit as real to them as ours are to us?


I'm not suggesting that every film is a lesson in empathy. Some films are designed to provoke, some to manipulate, some simply to entertain. And there's absolutely nothing wrong with spending two hours watching a silly comedy or a movie in which everything blows up.


But the opportunity to encounter another perspective is one of cinema's greatest gifts.


And nowhere is that opportunity more abundant than at a film festival.


I've spent much of my adult life at film festivals, and one of the things I love most is the unpredictability.


You are invited to a film you know almost nothing about. Perhaps it's from a country whose cinema you've never encountered. Perhaps the subject matter doesn't particularly interest you. Perhaps it's simply the only screening you could get into because everything else was sold out.


And sometimes, that film turns out to be the most memorable thing you see all week.


Not necessarily because you loved it.


Sometimes because you hated it.


Sometimes because it made you uncomfortable, challenged something you believed, or introduced you to an idea you hadn't considered.


And then something else happens.


You leave the theater.


You turn to the person sitting next to you and say, "Well, what did YOU think?"


And the conversation begins.


This is one of the best parts of traveling to film festivals with a group. People who have just watched the exact same film can emerge with wildly different reactions. Someone loves it. Someone hates it. Someone notices a detail nobody else caught. Someone interprets the ending in a completely different way.


And occasionally, someone says something that makes you reconsider your own opinion.


We don't necessarily change our minds. But we listen. We argue. We laugh. We defend our positions. And, most importantly, I hope we remain curious.


Movies have a long history of influencing social and political movements. Films like Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, Wag the Dog, Philadelphia, All the President’s Men, Twelve Years a Slave, An Inconvenient Truth, and Spotlight and countless others have helped bring important issues into public conversation.


But I'm interested in something less measurable.


Not whether a film inspired a protest, changed a law, or influenced an election.


I'm interested in whether the experience of watching films can make us better participants in the world around us.


More curious. More empathetic. More willing to question our assumptions. More comfortable with the idea that two people can look at the same thing and see something entirely different.


And perhaps more inclined to engage with people whose opinions differ from our own.


Because democracy doesn't begin and end at the ballot box.


It depends on our willingness to participate in a shared world, even when we don't agree about what that world should look like.


At a time when it's increasingly easy to retreat into our own carefully curated bubbles, there's still something special about the collective experience.  Something extraordinary about sitting in a dark theater with a room full of strangers, watching the same story unfold.


We may not agree about what we've seen.


But at least, for a moment, we've shared the experience.


And I think that's a pretty good place to start.


So, here's my question: Have you ever left a movie theater seeing something—or someone—differently than you did when you walked in?


I'd love to hear about it.



 
 
bottom of page